Just got a Logitech PS2 Cordless Action Controller, and this thing

It's weird. I actually tried out this highly regarded wireless controller back during the PS2 era and didn't like it. I think at that time I felt that the DualShock 2 was basically a perfect controller, and this officially licensed third-party wireless controller just felt too different to be

Logitech PlayStation 2 PS2 Cordless Action Controller G-X2D11 No Dongle/Receiver

I'm looking for a good quality PS2 wireless controller and these keep popping up. Are they as good as original and which of the two is better? Or are there better alternatives?

Logitech Wireless Action PlayStation 2 Controller Review + ss rf wireless controller sollution

Logitech G-X2D11 PlayStation 2 PS2 Cordless Action Wireless Controller Only 97855020932

Just got a Logitech PS2 Cordless Action Controller, and this thing rules Sony

I'm looking for a good quality PS2 wireless controller and these keep popping up. Are they as good as original and which of the two is better? Or are there better alternatives?